California: what the candidates said, in their own words

Election day: Nov 3, 26 days · California ballots went out Oct 5

Statewide Governor

Governor

Steve Hilton R

70 answers from 4 videos

Xavier Becerra D

95 answers from 4 videos

Describe your life or your worries in a sentence or two, and we will match them to the issues. We do not save what you type.

Show all issues

Where they stand, issue by issue

Each card sums up what the candidate said across every video we indexed. Each sentence links to the clip it comes from.

Taxes and cost of living

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes $3 gas, halving electric bills, exempting the first $100,000 of income from state income tax, and homes people can afford. ▶ 0:40 ▶ 35:40
  • Hilton says he would pay for tax cuts by cutting bureaucrats, fraud and error, high-speed rail, and nonprofit homelessness payments. ▶ 28:20 ▶ 1:40 ▶ 8:00
  • Hilton argues Democratic policies make California about $34,000 a year costlier than average, and says $70,000 earners pay 9.3% state tax. ▶ 30:20 ▶ 35:40
“$3 gas, cut your electric bills in half, your first 100 grand tax-free, a home you can afford to buy.”
Interview · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
“Cutting gas prices $3. Gas,electric bills. Cut your bills in half a home. You can afford to buy your first 100 grandfree of state income tax.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra argues Hilton's across-the-board tax cuts give billionaires a 40% tax break that would come out of schools, health care and housing. ▶ 3:00 ▶ 0:40 ▶ 2:00
  • Becerra proposes that high earners whose investments are taxed below a teacher's or firefighter's rate pay more, under predictable tax policy, alongside program cuts. ▶ 2:20 ▶ 4:20 ▶ 1:20
  • Becerra opposes the one-time billionaire tax initiative and proposes declaring a state of emergency to freeze property insurance and utility rates. ▶ 34:00 ▶ 66:00 ▶ 25:00
“You're going to end up giving the wealthiest Californians, billionaires, a 40% tax break, the biggest in California history.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“He wants to give the richest Californians, millionaires and billionaires, a 40% tax cut, which means of course he'll take it out of our schools, he'll take it out of health care”
Debate · CNN-News18

Health care

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes a working-class health care guarantee with a low premium and low deductible, funded by cutting waste and fraud. ▶ 49:20
  • Hilton opposes single-payer health care and proposes cutting state spending on health care for citizens of other countries. ▶ 13:00
  • Hilton says he is pro-vaccine and would follow vaccine law, but argues fewer mandates bring higher compliance and Becerra recommended masking toddlers. ▶ 44:40 ▶ 45:40 ▶ 47:40
“That's why I've announced my plan for a working class healthcare guarantee that will have a low premium and a low deductible by cutting out the waste and the fraud”
Debate · CNN-News18
“We're now spending 20 billion dollars when you add it all up on free health care in California for citizens of other countries.”
Interview · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra proposes keeping people on Medi-Cal, including undocumented immigrants, arguing early primary care costs less than emergency room care. ▶ 1:20 ▶ 27:40 ▶ 8:20
  • Becerra pledges not to kick people off coverage under federal work requirements and says Trump's health care cut will close rural hospitals. ▶ 51:20 ▶ 50:20
  • Becerra says HHS followed the science on vaccines, forced no one, and delivered about 700 million Covid shots without charge. ▶ 48:20 ▶ 14:00 ▶ 47:20
“That means keeping them on Medi-Cal so they can see the pediatrician or their family doc or their OB when they need to, not when it's an emergency”
Interview · San Francisco Chronicle
“Health care is different, and so to deny someone health care one is not only immoral, but two is not fiscally sound.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California

Immigration and the border

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton says he would follow SB 54, aim to lower the temperature, and prioritize removing criminals in the country illegally. ▶ 17:00 ▶ 18:20
  • Hilton argues that as HHS secretary Becerra dismantled sponsor vetting for migrant children and sent thousands to traffickers, citing a New York Times investigation. ▶ 22:40 ▶ 24:40
  • Hilton says Becerra's party is not enforcing California law, and denies Becerra's claim that he called for deporting every farm worker. ▶ 19:20 ▶ 20:40
“And so I would follow the law. And in fact, my goal here would be to lower the temperature”
Debate · CNN-News18
“We've got to get this whole debate back to where most people want it to be, which is to prioritize the removal of dangerous criminals.”
Debate · CNN-News18
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra supports a regulated immigration system and an enforcement agency but opposes family separation, deadly raids, and masked agents in unmarked vehicles. ▶ 21:40 ▶ 24:00 ▶ 25:40
  • Becerra proposes immigration reform so no young child is detained, and says Trump dismantled the care system for migrant children. ▶ 26:00 ▶ 24:00 ▶ 22:00
  • Becerra argues Hilton called Trump's ICE raids "perfect," said every California farm worker should be deported, and welcomed ICE "mercenaries." ▶ 20:20 ▶ 19:00
“It is good to have a regulated system of immigrants to come into our country, including California.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“we need immigration enforcement. We are a sovereign nation. We have a right to know who's coming into a to our through our borders, and we have a right to enforce a law.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California

Trump and Washington

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton says his focus is California and his relationship with President Trump and cabinet members would help him get a better deal. ▶ 38:40 ▶ 10:00
  • Hilton cites gas prices, forest management and the federal fraud task force as areas where that relationship would help. ▶ 10:00
  • Hilton says Democrats will make the race about Trump while he makes it about California. ▶ 37:40
“I do have a relationshipwith the president, and half the cabinet are friends.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California
“it's helpful for Californians to have a governor with a good relationship with the president.”
Interview · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra says Trump is withholding $30 billion for Altadena and Palisades fire survivors to force changes to voting law. ▶ 32:20 ▶ 33:40
  • Becerra cites suing the Trump administration about 120 times as attorney general, winning on the ACA, DACA, clean car standards and reproductive health. ▶ 43:00 ▶ 23:00 ▶ 9:40
  • Becerra proposes having state law enforcement set terms with federal agencies before deployments, and says California must get its fair federal share. ▶ 2:00 ▶ 61:20
“He's holding $30 billion hostage for the victims and survivors of the Altadena and Pacific Palisades fires because he wants his way on voting.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“30 billion is waiting to go to Pacific's Pacific Palisades and Altadena. Donald Trump doesn't want to let it go because Donald Trump isn't getting his way on elections.”
Debate · CNN-News18

Elections and voting

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton says the top-two primary has not produced moderation and proposes returning to the traditional primary system. ▶ 16:20 ▶ 49:20
  • Hilton says a majority of Californians find showing ID to vote reasonable, and argues voter ID will boost turnout. ▶ 38:20 ▶ 34:20
  • Hilton says a majority of Californians want change and argues 5.9 million votes would win statewide. ▶ 8:20 ▶ 34:20
“I do think this top two system uh has not really worked and I would be arguing for getting rid of it.”
Interview · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
“The top two system,I just think is a joke and should be, we should move away from it.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra opposes the Trump-backed Prop 39, which he says would make it harder for Californians to vote, and urges a no vote. ▶ 38:00
  • Becerra says Democrats should not shame voters and expects at least one Democrat in the November runoff. ▶ 58:40
  • Becerra wants voters to pay attention so money does not drive good candidates out of a shrinking field. ▶ 35:00
“Steve Hilton is supporting the Trump-backed Prop 39. That would make it harder for Cali- Californians to vote.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“Don't shame voters if they end up finding that the people that they vote for are not Democrats.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California

Housing and rent

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes capping government fees and regulations on a new home at $50,000 and building 10 new cities that counties bid to host. ▶ 5:00
  • Hilton wants communities, not Sacramento, to build the housing they need, and opposes forced suburban apartment construction and density-focused policy. ▶ 6:20 ▶ 5:00 ▶ 3:20
  • Hilton argues red tape from Becerra's party blocks communities that want to build, and says Becerra did nothing about it as attorney general. ▶ 8:00 ▶ 7:20
“I'm announcing tonight that I will cap that at $50,000. That is $150,000 off the price of a new home.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“Instead of the Sacramento forcing this onto communities, I want communities to to build the housing that meets their needs.”
Debate · CNN-News18
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra pledges to at least double the rate of home building by cutting red tape and fees and expanding down payment help. ▶ 6:20 ▶ 24:20
  • Becerra proposes limiting Wall Street buyers and funding the last tranche for about 40,000 shovel-ready affordable housing units. ▶ 6:20 ▶ 24:20
  • Becerra says no locality should block housing, citing his attorney general lawsuit against Huntington Beach. ▶ 7:40
“We will close the housing gap. I've said already that we have to at least double the rate of building of homes.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“About 40,000 units of affordable housing are essentially shovel ready,most, in most cases they're just missing that last tranche of funding.”
Interview · KCRA 3

Schools and education

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes making sure every student reads by third grade, using phonics, and holding teachers accountable. ▶ 56:40
  • Hilton argues schools under Democrats spend near the most for some of the worst results, with under half of students reading at grade level. ▶ 57:20 ▶ 56:40
“We need to make sure that every student reads by third grade. We need to use phonics in our school system to teach kids to read.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“Less as you said Jake, less than half the students read a grade level with math it's 37%.”
Debate · CNN-News18
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra proposes grade-level checks before promotion, tutoring, and affordable pre-K and child care so children start school ready to learn. ▶ 55:00 ▶ 13:00
  • Becerra proposes paying teachers like professionals and cutting bureaucracy to focus education spending on classrooms. ▶ 57:00 ▶ 14:00 ▶ 14:40
  • Becerra opposes sending public school dollars to private for-profit schools and supports reauthorizing the Prop 30 and Prop 55 school revenue. ▶ 55:00 ▶ 68:40
“What we have to do is make sure before we pass a child on, we're making sure that they are at grade level.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“Child care has become essentially paying collegetuition for your 2 and 3 year old while you go work.”
Interview · KCRA 3

Tech and AI

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes an immediate pause on AI in classrooms and wants California to first bring AI manufacturing and infrastructure jobs home. ▶ 9:40
  • Hilton says he will hold AI companies to their commitments and that California should lead in regulating the industry. ▶ 10:20 ▶ 9:40
  • Hilton argues Becerra cannot be trusted on AI because, he says, Becerra is funded by Big Tech and AI. ▶ 11:40
“And that's why I've said that we should have an immediate pause on AI in the classroom.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“it may require regulation and legislation. I think that should be led in California because this industry is here.”
Debate · CNN-News18
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra calls for AI enforcement and guardrails protecting children, workers facing job losses, public safety and privacy, saying Hilton is not interested in regulating AI. ▶ 11:00
  • Becerra wants AI to supplement rather than replace workers, and wants the AI industry based in California while sharing its benefits. ▶ 55:40 ▶ 58:00
  • Becerra supports data centers only when they add jobs, energy and water capacity, and cites suing Meta, Amazon and Google. ▶ 14:00 ▶ 58:00 ▶ 12:00
“He's not interested in regulating AI. He's not interested in telling these companies, you have to protect not just our kids and not just in school. You have to protect our workers”
Debate · CNN-News18
“what I'm saying is, if you've got someone who's working, doing the job that now I seems like it might be able to do somewhat, that doesn't mean you jettison the worker just like that.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California

Jobs and the economy

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton argues 16 years of one-party Democratic rule produced the highest poverty, unemployment and cost of living, and says most Californians want change. ▶ 2:00 ▶ 14:40
  • Hilton proposes cutting red tape to bring Hollywood home, and says most workers' earnings have been flat since the 1970s. ▶ 53:40 ▶ 41:00
“highest poverty rate in the country, highest unemployment rate of all 50 states, highest cost of living by far.”
Interview · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
“If you're Javier Becerra and you're the um candidate who is supported by the machine in Sacramento, the unions, big business”
Debate · CNN-News18
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra says about 50,000 film jobs have left and proposes production tax credits whenever the state gets more than $1 back per dollar. ▶ 52:40
  • Becerra cites helping enact the first federal film production tax credit and says he won a lawsuit stopping Trump from imposing California water standards. ▶ 54:00
“If we give a tax credit, so long as we get more than $1 back for that dollar in tax credit, we're going to do it.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“I was part of the team that enacted the first uh federal tax credit for film and movie production.”
Debate · CNN-News18

Gas and energy

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes $3 gas by producing oil and gas from California's own reserves instead of importing crude and gasoline. ▶ 5:00 ▶ 44:20
  • Hilton proposes halving electric bills by consolidating regulators, using existing natural gas plants more, and adding utility competition. ▶ 6:20 ▶ 50:40
“So, we're actually increasing carbon emissions as well as increasing cost. I would put all of that into reverse. That's the starting point is to use oil and gas from within California.”
Interview · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
“my my plan is to get to $3 gas.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra says gas costs $2 more than when Trump started the war in Iran, putting the national average above $4 a gallon. ▶ 28:40
  • Becerra says Hilton called firefighters bureaucrats. ▶ 28:40
“$2 more than it was when Donald Trump started the war in Iran.”
Debate · CNN-News18

Climate and environment

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes using California oil instead of imports, which he says cuts emissions and gas prices, and managing forests to reduce wildfire emissions. ▶ 26:40
  • Hilton says there is no evidence California's climate policies help the climate and argues they impose costs on working-class Californians. ▶ 2:00
“it makes absolutely no sense right now to do what we're doing, importing oil halfway around the world from the Middle East and from South America when we have abundant oil reserves here.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“And there's no evidence that any of California's climate policies are helping the climate.”
Interview · San Francisco Chronicle
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra argues Hilton would let polluters and Trump set energy policy, including oil drilling along the California coast. ▶ 28:00
  • Becerra says climate goals must be achievable, carbon neutrality by 2045 looks harder to reach, and working families may not yet manage electric vehicles. ▶ 28:40
“He wants to drill, baby, drill along the coast of California.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“So goals that are achievable, not goalsthat are pie in the sky.”
Interview · KCRA 3

Homelessness

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton says California needs a new homelessness plan rather than the same policy. ▶ 31:20
  • Hilton argues Becerra gave Newsom an A on homelessness after 16 years he calls a scandal. ▶ 31:20
“So, Javier gave when we were asked to give Gavin Newsom a grade on homelessness, he gave him an A.”
Debate · CNN-News18
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra pledges to clear encampments, enforce the law, address mental health and addiction, and fund help keeping people in their homes. ▶ 30:20
  • Becerra wants accountability, moving funding from homelessness groups that do not deliver results to those that do. ▶ 5:40 ▶ 30:20
“What we will do is we will make sure the encampments are cleared.”
Debate · CNN-News18
“I wanna have accountability. I'm willing to invest in in having uhassistance for those who are homeless, but we have to have results.”
Interview · KCRA 3

Water and wildfires

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton proposes managing fuel loads by clearing brush and reviving timber harvesting, and says state agencies fined Palisades residents for clearing brush. ▶ 53:40
  • Hilton says withheld fire money is what Newsom promised, including $2.5 billion, and that Los Angeles families still await Newsom's aid. ▶ 32:40
“All you actually have to dois get back to common sense, which we've done for centuries,which is you manage the fuel load”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California
“the money that's being withheld is actually the money that Gavin Newsom promised”
Debate · CNN-News18
Xavier Becerra D

No answer on record about this in 4 videos we indexed.

Crime and public safety

Steve Hilton R

No answer on record about this in 4 videos we indexed.

Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra says the state has authority and an obligation to investigate a death during a federal ICE action. ▶ 4:20
  • Becerra proposes setting rules of engagement with federal agents beforehand. ▶ 4:20
“An incident has occurred that took the life of an individual. We have authority to investigate. We have an obligation to investigate.”
Interview · San Francisco Chronicle

Record and trust

Steve Hilton R
  • Hilton says he is a first-time candidate with a business background, not a career politician, and an outsider who can shake up the system. ▶ 17:20 ▶ 1:00 ▶ 22:20
  • Hilton says he grew up in a working-class immigrant family, attended Oxford, and advised David Cameron before moving to California. ▶ 10:00
  • Hilton argues Becerra never created a job in 36 years as a career politician, and says Becerra's backers produced the worst homelessness and highest costs. ▶ 12:40 ▶ 16:00
“This is the first time I've run for office. I'm not a career politician. I'm not an ideologue. I'm very pragmatic.”
Interview · KTVU FOX 2 San Francisco
“So I think it is a strong argument that I make when I say it is time for an outsider to shake up a system that isn't working.”
Interview · San Francisco Chronicle
Xavier Becerra D
  • Becerra cites decades in Congress, as attorney general and at HHS, and says he is the only candidate who has managed budgets California's size. ▶ 13:00 ▶ 7:00 ▶ 0:20
  • Becerra says his immigrant parents, a construction worker and a clerical worker, built a stable life, and he wants that chance for similar families. ▶ 3:40 ▶ 51:40
  • Becerra says he was misled by people he trusted on campaign payments, calls them substantial but not illegal, and says everyone is accountable. ▶ 18:40 ▶ 21:20 ▶ 20:00
“I'm the only candidate who's actually managed budgets and balanced budgets that are as big as the budget of the state of California.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California
“So I made a quick decision, decided to run, got won a race, came out of nowhere in 1990 and and two years later, 92 got to Congress, served 25 years.”
Forum · Commonwealth Club World Affairs of California

Videos we used

Each of these shows the candidate speaking.

How we pick and mark clips