Michigan: what the candidates said, in their own words

Election day: Nov 3, 26 days

Statewide U.S. Senate Governor

Governor

John James R

68 answers from 6 videos

Jocelyn Benson D

84 answers from 7 videos

Describe your life or your worries in a sentence or two, and we will match them to the issues. We do not save what you type.

Show all issues

Where they stand, issue by issue

Each card sums up what the candidate said across every video we indexed. Each sentence links to the clip it comes from.

Health care

John James R
  • James proposes price tags for patients and transparency rules to hold insurers, hospitals, drug companies and PBMs accountable. ▶ 0:40 ▶ 46:00
  • James says Medicaid stays for people working 80 hours and caregivers, and he would seek hardship exemptions and target fraud. ▶ 38:40 ▶ 36:40
  • James proposes a prevention-first approach with cleaner food, less exposure to dyes, PFAS and pesticides, and more community mental health resources. ▶ 4:00 ▶ 2:40 ▶ 3:40
“I also believe very strongly in patients deserving price tags. That's increasing transparency to hold the insurance companies and the hospitals and and the the pharmaceutical companies and the PBMs accountable for their cartel-like behavior.”
Campaign video · John James
“I believe very strongly my patients deserve price tags that will increase transparency and lower costs for everyone”
Debate · WOOD TV8
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson proposes a health care affordability board to examine price gouging and lower premium and prescription drug costs. ▶ 16:20 ▶ 7:20 ▶ 5:00
  • Benson proposes streamlining the health department so people keep benefits, using existing state data for eligibility and helping patients appeal insurance denials. ▶ 7:20 ▶ 38:00 ▶ 7:20
  • Benson proposes Medicaid-covered doula and midwifery services to address Black maternal health gaps, and wants Rx Kids for every child. ▶ 3:20 ▶ 0:40 ▶ 8:20
“creating a health care affordability board, which 12 other states have done that we have not done, that can examine price gouging”
Interview · WDET 101.9 FM Detroit
“We want to launch an affordability a healthcare affordability board that's comprised of stakeholders. They're in place in nearly a dozen states.”
Interview · Mid-Michigan now on FOX66 & NBC25

Elections and voting

John James R
  • James says the government owes voters answers on election security and says the Secretary of State admitted allowing 16 illegals to vote. ▶ 5:00
  • James says he works across the aisle, citing an anti-trafficking bill, and that 8,000 Michiganders have invested in his campaign. ▶ 39:40 ▶ 42:00
  • James says he has won twice in Southeast Michigan since his 2020 loss in a pandemic year. ▶ 5:00
“we have a Secretary of State who's admitted to allowing 16 illegals vote in uh in past elections”
Interview · CBS Detroit
“I can work with anyone and everyone who will help make 10 million”
Debate · FOX 2 Detroit
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson says audits and recounts confirmed the 2020 election was secure and that the FBI action rehashes disproven conspiracy theories. ▶ 2:40 ▶ 3:40
  • Benson says Michigan is planning for scenarios including federal troops at polls, and as governor she would stand in their way. ▶ 8:00 ▶ 6:20 ▶ 9:20
  • Benson argues state officials of every party must stand up to federal threats and use every tool to protect voters. ▶ 1:00 ▶ 10:40 ▶ 12:00
“In Michigan, we did over 250 audits of that election.”
Interview · CBS News
“it leads to threats against us, against election officials, against local officials, against our families, our staff.”
Interview · CBS News

Taxes and cost of living

John James R
  • James says he identified up to $3 billion in Lansing waste, fraud and unspent funds to return to taxpayers. ▶ 8:40
  • James proposes a day-one audit of state spending and would first cut MEDC strategic funds, which he calls corporate welfare. ▶ 8:00 ▶ 9:00
  • James says the state must grow, not only cut, and proposes reforming road funding so EVs pay their share. ▶ 9:40 ▶ 42:40
“It's up to three billion that we can use to put more money back in your pockets and spur and grow the economy.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“we need to audit on day one to figure out what they're doing”
Interview · Click On Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson proposes a $5,000 tax credit for families caring for an aging relative and tax relief for parents paying for child care. ▶ 10:40 ▶ 11:20
  • Benson says she has no plans to raise middle-class taxes and would review the tax code to close loopholes for the wealthy. ▶ 3:40 ▶ 43:40 ▶ 5:40
  • Benson says auto insurance laws need reform because changes made a few years ago have raised costs. ▶ 5:40
“Included in those tax credits will be a $5,000 tax credit for long-term care.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“Any family who is providing long-term care for an aging loved one will qualify for a $5,000 tax credit”
Debate · WOOD TV8

Schools and education

John James R
  • James proposes Mississippi-style literacy policies focused on phonics and the science of reading, and says half of education dollars miss classrooms. ▶ 16:00
  • James says third-grade retention is on the table, with repeated testing and tutoring. ▶ 18:40
  • James proposes protecting parental rights, making the board of education report to the governor, and opting into a federal scholarship program. ▶ 1:20 ▶ 9:20 ▶ 18:40
“We need to focus on phonics. We need to focus on the science of of reading. We need to focus on literacy.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“A retention is absolutely on the table and we have to make sure that we're doing it in a manner that doesn't hurt or crush the spirit of the child.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson proposes a plan with a Michigan education guarantee, better teacher pay, a weighted funding formula and early childhood investment. ▶ 17:40 ▶ 0:00 ▶ 2:00
  • Benson says the state should stop raiding the school aid fund and distribute school money more transparently and equitably. ▶ 3:20
  • Benson says teachers, not politicians, should decide whether a third grader repeats a grade, and would expand current literacy investments. ▶ 19:20 ▶ 7:40
“It includes a Michigan education guarantee that will ensure our kids are college or career ready no matter what public school they graduate from.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“we have to redo our one-size-fits-all funding model and replace it with a weighted equitable model.”
Interview · Click On Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV

Tech and AI

John James R
  • James backs a moratorium on new data centers until communities are protected, with local control and protection of water and electric bills. ▶ 36:40 ▶ 23:20
  • James wants no NDAs on data centers and siting on brownfields over farmland, and says Benson's running mate signed an NDA on Saline. ▶ 36:40 ▶ 23:20 ▶ 29:20
  • James says Fourth Amendment privacy rights are non-negotiable and, on Flock cameras, he would protect local control and constitutional rights. ▶ 41:20
“We absolutely cannot have an additional data center.”
Debate · FOX 2 Detroit
“we must have local control. Our electricity bills can't go up. We need to protect our water, prevent pollution that includes air, land, water, and noise pollution.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson proposes a moratorium on new data centers until guardrails protect local control, water and energy costs. ▶ 25:00 ▶ 13:40 ▶ 9:00
  • Benson supports ending non-disclosure agreements for data center projects and requiring transparency and community benefits agreements. ▶ 28:20 ▶ 13:40
  • Benson says the state should set guardrails on surveillance technology like Flock cameras while preserving local control. ▶ 40:20
“I've called for a moratorium on any new data center developments until we have real guardrails in place to protect local control, protect our water”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“We have a moral responsibility to protect our water, to protect our Great Lakes, to drive down energy costs, and require transparency”
Interview · WDET 101.9 FM Detroit

Gas and energy

John James R
  • James supports a temporary state gas tax holiday paid for with MEDC money and cuts to pork, fraud and waste in Lansing. ▶ 13:20 ▶ 17:20
  • James proposes repealing the Public Act 235 clean energy mandate for an all-of-the-above approach with renewables, natural gas and nuclear. ▶ 21:40
  • James says Michigan median household income is $9,000 below the national median. ▶ 13:20
“But what I can do is I can call for a gas tax holiday. What we can do is use the MEEDC money to really put it back toward the people.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“look at the pork in Lancing.”
Debate · FOX 2 Detroit
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson proposes ending profit-driven utility rate hikes by reforming the Public Service Commission, modernizing the grid and investing in clean energy. ▶ 18:00 ▶ 16:40 ▶ 20:40
  • Benson says she is open to suspending the state gas tax and calls for a federal gas tax holiday. ▶ 12:20 ▶ 14:20
  • Benson argues James voted six times to support the Iran war that raised gas prices. ▶ 14:20 ▶ 12:20
“I think that Michigan Public Service Commission needs to be reformed to ensure that we have again clear guardrails uh around what rate rate hikes are acceptable”
Interview · WDET 101.9 FM Detroit
“making sure we are ending unfair rate increases that are profit-driven, and instead working together to modernize our grid.”
Interview · WDET 101.9 FM Detroit

Jobs and the economy

John James R
  • James says Michigan ranks 46th overall and proposes to bring costs down, raise wages and end corruption in Lansing. ▶ 2:00
  • James says he never voted to raise tariffs on Canada, urged a fair deal with Canada, and proposes passing his Trade Act. ▶ 6:00 ▶ 7:20
  • James argues states have no role in international agreements and says Whitmer's subnational agreement created no jobs. ▶ 7:20
“Michigan is 42nd in infrastructure, 43rd in economy, 45th in education, 46th overall. That means 90% of this country is doing better than us”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“I've actually never voted to increase tariffs on Canada, despite what she says. And I've actually called out the administration, specifically talking with the trade ambassador”
Debate · WOOD TV8
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson proposes calling Canada on day one to negotiate a subnational agreement that removes tariff costs in Michigan. ▶ 4:40 ▶ 6:40
  • Benson says tariffs cost each Michigan household $5,600 and that James voted in February 2023 to give Trump tariff power. ▶ 4:40 ▶ 6:40
  • Benson argues Trump's tariff wars have not improved Michigan's economy, costs or jobs. ▶ 13:00
“On day one in office, I will call Canada and negotiate a contract between Michigan and Canada to eliminate the tariffs and the costs in Michigan. This is called a subnational agreement.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“So, in February of 2023, my opponent voted to give Trump the power to impose these taxes, these tariffs on Michigan.”
Debate · WOOD TV8

Trump and Washington

John James R
  • James says he can agree with Trump without worshiping him and disagree without attacking him, always putting Michigan first. ▶ 35:20 ▶ 11:00
  • James opposes the Iran war, saying it must end quickly, and says Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon. ▶ 53:00 ▶ 35:20
  • James says he would call the president to bring more resources to Michigan, which gets 40% of its budget federally. ▶ 6:00
“I've said that I can agree with the president without worshiping him. I can disagree without attacking him, and I always put Michigan first.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“I can disagree without attacking him.”
Debate · FOX 2 Detroit
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson says she will stand up to the president when he harms residents, and work with anyone to reduce costs and add jobs. ▶ 7:40 ▶ 5:00
  • Benson cites refusing Trump's demand for Michigan voters' private data and winning in court. ▶ 5:00
  • Benson argues James has not stood up to the president once in four years in Congress. ▶ 35:00
“the chaotic economic decisions that he's making that's driving up the cost of just about everything from gasoline prices to energy costs”
Interview · WDET 101.9 FM Detroit
“When President Trump recently tried to uh you know, pressure me to turn over the private voting data of Michigan citizens, I said no and I'll see you in court and we won.”
Interview · CBS Detroit

Housing and rent

John James R
  • James proposes rolling back regulations that make home building more difficult and expanding workforce development. ▶ 48:20
  • James says he has a bill to protect supply chains and is moving a path to affordable housing through the House. ▶ 48:20
“I have actually worked on a path to affordable housing. That is what we are doing. Moving that through the house and also rolling back harmful regulations that make it more difficult.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson proposes streamlining home construction to increase supply and down payment support for first- and second-time buyers. ▶ 3:00 ▶ 46:40 ▶ 16:40
  • Benson proposes holding out-of-state developers and investors accountable for driving up rents, and ending tariffs on building supplies. ▶ 16:40 ▶ 46:40
“So, our housing plan does three things. One, it increases supply of affordable homes by streamlining how homes are built”
Interview · CBS Detroit
“That's why my plan for affordable housing has three pieces to it. Streamlining how homes are built, eliminating a lot of those construction uh obstructions that stand in the way.”
Debate · WOOD TV8

Immigration and the border

John James R
  • James says he would cooperate with federal law enforcement, prioritize violent offenders, and does not expect ICE presence to be needed in Michigan. ▶ 34:20
  • James argues criticism of ICE is about opposing Trump and says the state should follow the rule of law. ▶ 7:00
“frankly, I don't believe we're going to need ICE presence in the state of Michigan because we are going to be enforcing the law.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“It's about being against Trump.”
Interview · Click On Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson says she would follow what the law and Constitution require on ICE and oppose masked federal agents in communities. ▶ 32:00
  • Benson says agents must be allowed into schools when there is clear danger, but opposes enforcement that traumatizes children. ▶ 31:00
“It all gets down to what does the law say? what does the Constitution require and ensuring that we don't have masked federal agents coming to our communities”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“So certainly there's going to be times where there's evidence of a clear and present danger in a school and we have to allow that to happen.”
Debate · WOOD TV8

Crime and public safety

John James R
  • James proposes holding judges, prosecutors and DAs who release violent offenders accountable, plus community policing and jobs for returning citizens. ▶ 33:00
  • James says the Minnesota loss of life could have been avoided by abiding by the law, and he would cooperate with federal law enforcement. ▶ 3:20 ▶ 4:00
  • James says he would not need to activate the National Guard because Michigan would cooperate with federal law. ▶ 5:40
“We're going to use we're going to use checks and balances to make sure that people who are making communities less safe are held accountable by the people.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“when I'm governor, I'm going to abide by the law because no one's above the law. Uh we're going to make sure that we are abiding by federal law.”
Speech · Mid-Michigan now on FOX66 & NBC25
Jocelyn Benson D

No answer on record about this in the 7 videos we indexed.

Climate and environment

John James R
  • James proposes moving away from Public Act 235, having utilities invest in resilience, and investing in underground infrastructure against floods. ▶ 49:40
  • James says Michigan must be resilient to severe weather in every season and argues preventing wildfires has the most impact on man-made climate causes. ▶ 2:40 ▶ 1:40
“We also need to make sure that we're investing in our underground infrastructure.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“I'm saying that we absolutely need to make sure that we are resilient for extreme weather”
Interview · CBS Detroit
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson says the recent natural disasters are a direct result of climate change and that Michigan can lead on it. ▶ 50:20
  • Benson proposes growing clean energy and climate tech jobs with research universities. ▶ 50:20
“I think it's very clear that the natural disasters you mentioned are a directly result of climate change and Michigan has an opportunity to lead on that area.”
Debate · WOOD TV8

Guns

John James R

No answer on record about this in the 6 videos we indexed.

Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson says gun violence must be reduced in schools, places of worship and communities, and law enforcement and partners need tools to do it. ▶ 8:20
“We need to protect our schools. We need to protect our communities against with gun violence, uh whether it's here in an education institution, at a place of worship, or in any community.”
Interview · Click On Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV

Water and wildfires

John James R
  • James says he is pressing Canada to manage its wildfires and cover costs incurred by Americans. ▶ 1:00
  • James proposes Michigan address its own down timber left by ice storms. ▶ 1:00
“Canada is properly incentivized to manage their own affairs and cover any costs that are incurred by Americans”
Interview · CBS Detroit
Jocelyn Benson D

No answer on record about this in the 7 videos we indexed.

Record and trust

John James R
  • James cites his record as a combat veteran, business leader and congressman, and says he works across the aisle. ▶ 54:40 ▶ 3:20 ▶ 2:40
  • James proposes disclosing his personal finances as governor the same way he does in Congress. ▶ 0:40
  • James says he holds disclosed mutual funds, denies supporting the data center measures, and argues Benson omitted her husband's income. ▶ 24:00 ▶ 26:00 ▶ 45:00
“I'm a combat veteran who understands what it takes to bring people together to accomplish tough and dangerous missions.”
Debate · WOOD TV8
“for a state where 40% of our budget comes from the federal resources in the first place, having someone who can deliver for people of the state of Michigan”
Interview · CBS Detroit
Jocelyn Benson D
  • Benson cites her Secretary of State record, saying she cut wait times, transformed the agency and moved Michigan's election ranking from 31st to second. ▶ 2:20 ▶ 9:00 ▶ 27:20
  • Benson says her family has not benefited from data centers, and argues James was fined for not disclosing and took pharmaceutical PAC money. ▶ 14:40 ▶ 45:40 ▶ 26:40
  • Benson proposes voluntarily complying with FOIA as governor and expanding her office's FOIA portal statewide. ▶ 12:20
“As Secretary of State, I've done that while also expanding our democracy, taking our elections from being ranked 31st in the nation to number two”
Interview · CBS Detroit
“Well, Secretary of State, I've taken our second largest agency next to Health and Human Services and transformed it. It was once a poster child for inefficiency.”
Speech · Lisa Roose-Church

Videos we used

Each of these shows the candidate speaking.

How we pick and mark clips